시그래프아시아 2022에 등록해주셔서 감사합니다. 대넌 시드니 행사에서 뵐께요. 더 자세한 정보는 여기로

시그래프아시아 2022에 등록해주셔서 감사합니다. 대넌 시드니 행사에서 뵐께요. 더 자세한 정보는 여기로

2022년 12월 6일~9일 | 대한민국 대구 엑스코(EXCO)

  • EnglishEnglish

#SIGGRAPHAsia | #SIGGRAPHAsia2022

Search

Search

Search

빠른 링크

  • A-Z 사이트맵
  • 메일 수신 안내
  • 시그래프 아시아 2022 위원회
  • 문의
  • 지금 신청하세요
  • EnglishEnglish

#SIGGRAPHAsia | #SIGGRAPHAsia2022

Search

Search

Search

빠른 링크

  • A-Z 사이트맵
  • 메일 수신 안내
  • 시그래프 아시아 2022 위원회
  • 문의
  • 지금 신청하세요
SIGGRAPH Asia 2022 SIGGRAPH Asia 2022 SIGGRAPH Asia 2022

6 – 9 December 2022 | EXCO, Daegu, South Korea

  • 소개
    • 시그래프 아시아
    • 개요
    • 시그래프 아시아 2022 위원회
    • 쾰른메쎄 운영사무국
    • 지원 & 파트너
    • 메일 수신 안내
    • 문의
    • A-Z 사이트맵
    • 시그래프 아시아 2023
    • 시그래프 아시아 유치
  • 프로그램
    • 컨퍼런스
      • Conference Proceedings
      • 행사 프로그램
      • 기조 강연자
      • 어워드 수상자
      • 아트 갤러리
      • 버드 오브 페더
      • 비즈니스 & 혁신 심포지엄
      • 컴퓨터 애니메이션 페스티벌
      • 코스
      • 다양성, 형평성 및 포용성
      • 이멀징 테크놀로지
      • 특집 세션
      • 게임
      • 기조강연
      • 포스터
      • 실시간 라이브
      • 테크 커뮤니케이션
      • 기술 논문
      • XR(Extended Reality)
    • 전시회
      • 전시 참관
      • 참여기업 토크
    • 정보 & 계획
      • 일반 정보
      • 모바일 앱 & 비즈매칭
      • 모바일 앱 & 비즈매칭 FAQ
      • 연사소개
      • 참여자 FAQ
  • 제출 안내
    • Art Gallery
    • Birds Of A Feather
    • Computer Animation Festival
    • Courses
    • Diversity, Equity and Inclusion
    • Emerging Technologies
    • Posters
    • Real-Time Live!
    • Technical Communications
    • Technical Papers
      • Ethics of the Review Process
      • Reviewer Instructions
      • Review Form
      • Conflict of Interest Rules for Authors
    • XR
    • 학생 자원봉사자
    • 온라인 제출
    • 논문 참가자 주의사항
    • 연사 소개
      • Speaker Preparation
      • Speaker Preparation & Practice Booking Forms
      • Speaker Room Equipment
      • Presentation Format & Guidelines
    • 특별 혜택
    • 제출 정보
    • Blank
    • Blank
  • 전시 및 협찬
    • 브랜딩및후원브로셔
  • 자원봉사
    • 학생 자원봉사자
    • 반폭력 정책
  • 미디어
    • 미디어 승인
    • 프레스룸
    • 미디어 파트너
    • 로고 및 가이드라인
    • 브랜딩 & 마케팅 키트
  • 등록 및 참관 안내
    • 일반 정보
    • 등록 분류 & 등록비
      • Full Access
      • Experience Plus Access
      • Experience Access
      • On-Demand Access
    • 왜 참석해야 하나요?
    • 참석 승인 요청 (회사 제출용)
    • 참여자 FAQ
    • 대구 방문 안내
    • 호텔 예약
    • 호텔 셔틀버스 & 투어
    • 비자 정보
    • 대구 소개
    • 장소

Search

Search

Search

빠른 링크

  • A-Z 사이트맵
  • 메일 수신 안내
  • 시그래프 아시아 2022 위원회
  • 문의
  • 지금 신청하세요
  1. Home
  2. 제출 안내
  3. Technical Papers
  4. Reviewer Instructions

Share this page

Reviewer Instructions

  • Art Gallery
  • Birds Of A Feather
  • Computer Animation Festival
  • Courses
  • Diversity, Equity and Inclusion
  • Emerging Technologies
  • Posters
  • Real-Time Live!
  • Technical Communications
  • Technical Papers
  • Ethics of the Review Process
  • Reviewer Instructions
  • Review Form
  • Conflict of Interest Rules for Authors
  • XR
  • 학생 자원봉사자
  • 온라인 제출
  • 논문 참가자 주의사항
  • 연사 소개
  • Speaker Preparation
  • Speaker Preparation & Practice Booking Forms
  • Speaker Room Equipment
  • Presentation Format & Guidelines
  • 특별 혜택
  • 제출 정보

Thank you for agreeing to review a paper for SIGGRAPH Asia. Reviews have a direct and important impact on the quality of the most important conference in computer graphics. Reviews also help the computer-graphics community to improve the quality of its research. To access review materials and the web review forms, please login to the online submission system using your standard submission account.

What to Look For

Look for what’s good or stimulating in the paper. Minor flaws can be corrected and shouldn’t be a reason to reject a paper. Each paper that is accepted must, however, be technically sound and make a substantial contribution to the field. Please familiarize yourself with the information in the Call for Submissions.

Ethics & Professionalism
Please read the . It is extremely important that we uphold our reputation for treating ideas confidentially and professionally. By accepting a paper for review, you are guaranteeing to review all materials submitted in the approved formats: PDF for documents; QuickTime, MPEG, and DivX Version 6 for videos (and don’t forget to check for an audio track!); and TIFF, PNG or JPG for images. If you are not willing to make this guarantee, please recuse yourself from reviewing the paper.

You are also expected to make a reasonable effort to review materials in non-approved formats, but you are not under the same absolute obligation to do so.

Blind Reviews
We are using double-blind reviewing. This anonymity is an integral part of an objective and fair review process as supported by statistical data and extensive research record [1,2] (please refer to those papers for further references).

Authors were asked to take reasonable efforts to hide their identities, including not listing their names or affiliations and omitting acknowledgements. This information will, of course, be included in the published version, should the paper be accepted. The identity of the reviewers is not disclosed to the authors, either during or after the reviewing process, even after a possible acceptance of the submission. As a reviewer, it is your responsibility to write the review and any bulletin board communications in such a way that your identity remains protected.

One area where anonymity can affect your evaluation of the submitted paper is if the paper builds on ideas that were previously available in some prepublication form, for instance as a SIGGRAPH/SIGGRAPH Asia Talk, or as a technical report or thesis. The authors were instructed to avoid plagiarism, and to cite their sources if they used ideas from somebody else’s work. Authors do not cite their own prepublications of largely overlapping works to avoid revealing their identity (see ). Reviewers should not deliberately try to discover the identity of the authors. An incidental discovery of the authors prepublication must not be held against the reviewed submission. Immediately following the submission deadline, plagiarism detection software will be run on all submissions, and the sorting team will further ascertain originality of submissions during the sort when needed. If you as a reviewer have a substantial concern regarding the originality of the submission, please contact the SIGGRAPH Asia Technical Papers Administrator prior to submitting your review.

Due to the number of new works posted on arXiv and other non-peer-reviewed websites on a daily basis, it is increasingly likely that you might find online reports that are highly relevant to the submitted work, and that the authors were unaware of. In this case, authors of conditionally accepted papers should be asked to cite these prepublications in their final revision. Note that authors are allowed to cite them as concurrent work, without the burden of having to detail how their work compares or differs from these prepublications.

Be Specific
Please be specific and detailed in your reviews. In the discussion of related work and references, simply saying “this is well known” or “this has been common practice in the industry for years” is not sufficient: please cite specific publications or public disclosures of techniques! The Explanation section is easily the most important of the review. Your discussion, sometimes more than your score, will help the Papers Committee decide which papers to accept, so please be thorough. Your reviews will be returned to the authors, so you should include any specific feedback on ways the authors can improve their papers. For more suggestions on writing your reviews, please read Greg Turk’s webpage on Writing Technical Reviews.

Online Review
To access electronically-submitted papers and supplemental material, log in to the online submission system the same way you would to make a submission to SIGGRAPH Asia, using your existing electronic submission account. Once you have logged in, access the “Submissions & Reviews” portion of the site at the top of the screen, and use the links in your To-Do List. If you have any questions or problems with the online review system, use the “Contact Support” link at the bottom of the page.

ACM & Eurographics Digital Libraries
ACM and Eurographics have generously provided full access to their respective Digital Libraries for SIGGRAPH Asia paper reviewer usage during the review period. You are encouraged to make full use of these resources:

ACM Digital Library
Eurographics Digital Library

You must login to access the full text of an article. A username and password will be made available via our electronic review system to each reviewer.

Timely Reviews
The deadline for completed reviews is Monday, 11 July 2022, 23:59 AoT. Adhering to this deadline is extremely important. In particular, the author rebuttal process starts immediately after the review deadline, where authors must be able to see the complete set of reviews.

When You’re Done
In previous years, these guidelines said “after the review process, destroy all copies of papers and videos that are not returned to the senior reviewer and erase any implementations you have written to evaluate the ideas in the papers, as well as any results of those implementations.”

However, SIGGRAPH Asia now has a process for revised papers that were rejected from a previous SIGGRAPH/SIGGRAPH Asia conference, where the authors can choose to release the previous reviewers’ names, so that the same reviewers can be reassigned. Therefore, there is a chance that you will be asked in the future to review such a resubmission, and may need your notes, marked manuscripts, or implementations. So you may keep them if necessary, but please be careful to insulate the ideas you learned from the review from your own research, and from your colleagues and students. Also, please be aware that your reviews may be perused by other future SIGGRAPH/SIGGRAPH Asia reviewers.

[1] Reviewer bias in single- versus double-blind peer review. A. Tomkins, M. Zhang, and W.D. Heavlin. PNAS, 2017, 114 (48). https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1707323114
[2] Effectiveness of Anonymization in Double-Blind Review. C. Le Goues, Y. Brun, S. Apel, E. Berger, S. Khurshid, Y. Smaragdakis. Communications of the ACM, 2018, 61 (6), https://doi.org/10.1145/3208157



SUBMISSIONS

  • DEADLINES
  • KEY INFO

SPONSOR OR EXHIBIT

  • WHY PARTICIPATE?
  • DOWNLOAD BROCHURE

RESOURCES

  • Facts & Figures
  • FOR SPEAKERS
  • FOR PRESS

DIRECTORIES

  • A-Z 사이트맵
  • 시그래프 아시아 2022 위원회

GET IN TOUCH

  • 문의
  • 메일 수신 안내

EVENT POLICIES

  • ANTI-HARASSMENT
  • ACM PRIVACY POLICY
  • REGISTRATION POLICY

#SIGGRAPHAsia2022

  • 미디어

Sponsored by ACM SIGGRAPH footer 1  footer 1

© SIGGRAPH Asia 2022

Organized by footer logo 1

  • 소개
    • 시그래프 아시아
    • 개요
    • 시그래프 아시아 2022 위원회
    • 쾰른메쎄 운영사무국
    • 지원 & 파트너
    • 메일 수신 안내
    • 문의
    • A-Z 사이트맵
    • 시그래프 아시아 2023
    • 시그래프 아시아 유치
  • 프로그램
    • 컨퍼런스
      • Conference Proceedings
      • Full Program
      • 기조 강연자
      • 어워드 수상자
      • 아트 갤러리
      • 버드 오브 페더
      • 비즈니스 & 혁신 심포지엄
      • 컴퓨터 애니메이션 페스티벌
      • 코스
      • 다양성, 형평성 및 포용성
      • 이멀징 테크놀로지
      • 특집 세션
      • 게임
      • 기조강연
      • 포스터
      • 실시간 라이브
      • 테크 커뮤니케이션
      • 기술 논문
      • XR(Extended Reality)
    • 전시회
      • 전시 참관
      • 참여기업 토크
    • 정보 & 계획
      • 일반 정보
      • 등록 분류 & 등록비
      • 연사소개
      • 참여자 FAQ
  • 제출 안내
    • Art Gallery
    • Birds Of A Feather
    • Computer Animation Festival
    • Courses
    • Emerging Technologies
    • Posters
    • Technical Communications
    • Technical Papers
      • Ethics of the Review Process
      • Reviewer Instructions
      • Review Form
      • Conflict of Interest Rules for Authors
    • XR
    • 학생 자원봉사자
    • 온라인 제출
    • 논문 참가자 주의사항
    • Information For Speakers
    • 특별 혜택
    • 제출 정보
  • 전시 및 협찬
    • 브랜딩및후원브로셔
  • 자원봉사
    • 학생 자원봉사자
    • 반폭력 정책
  • 미디어
    • 미디어 파트너
    • 로고 및 가이드라인
    • Branding & Marketing Kit
  • 등록 및 참관 안내
    • 일반 정보
    • 등록 분류 & 등록비
      • Full Access
      • Experience Plus Access
      • Experience Access
      • On-Demand Access
    • 왜 참석해야 하나요?
    • 참석 승인 요청 (회사 제출용)
    • 참여자 FAQ
    • 대구 방문 안내
    • Hotel Reservations
    • Visa Information
    • 대구 소개
    • 장소
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
Cookie SettingsAccept All
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
SAVE & ACCEPT
noscript>